Most mid-sized companies do not have a recruiting problem. They have a recruiting model problem. The same team that fills entry-level roles in two weeks can spend six months on a controller, a cleared data engineer or a department manager, because the model that works for one search is the wrong tool for the other.
There are three common ways to run talent acquisition: contingency recruiting, retained search and in-house recruiting. Each has a place. The mistake is using one model for every role.
What contingency recruiting is
In contingency recruiting, an outside firm sources and submits candidates, and you pay a fee only if you hire one of them. The fee is usually a percentage of the hire's first-year base salary. There is no upfront cost and no fee if the search does not end in a hire.
Contingency works best when:
- The role is well defined and the requirements are clear
- You need speed and want several firms or channels working at once
- The hiring manager can review candidates and give feedback quickly
- The cost of a vacancy is high but the role is not a one-of-one executive seat
The tradeoff is commitment. A contingency firm is paid on results, so the best firms put their effort into clients who respond quickly, share real feedback and treat them as a partner rather than a resume vendor.
What retained search is
In retained search, you pay part of the fee upfront to secure a firm's dedicated time on one search. Retained firms typically run a deeper process: market mapping, outreach to a defined target list, structured assessment and a shortlist.
Retained search fits when:
- The role is senior, confidential or rare in the market
- You are replacing someone who is still in the seat
- You need a documented process for a board, investors or a prime contractor
- A bad hire would cost far more than the search itself
What in-house recruiting is
An in-house recruiter or talent acquisition team works only on your roles. They know your culture, your hiring managers and your systems, and they build a pipeline over time. For steady, repeatable hiring, in-house is usually the most cost-effective model.
The limits show up on niche roles. An internal team that fills operations and support roles well may not have the networks to find a CPA with a specific tax specialty, a geotechnical engineer ready to lead a department, or a candidate holding an active TS/SCI with a full scope polygraph.
How to choose: match the model to the role
| Situation | Best fit | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Steady, repeatable hiring in core roles | In-house | Lowest cost per hire over time, strongest culture fit |
| Hard-to-fill specialist roles with clear requirements | Contingency | Outside networks, no fee unless you hire |
| Urgent openings tied to revenue or a contract | Contingency | Speed and reach into passive candidates |
| Senior, confidential or one-of-one leadership seats | Retained | Dedicated process and deep market mapping |
| Key personnel for a government proposal | Contingency or retained | Depends on how many named roles and how early the bid is |
Many companies land on a blend: an in-house team for steady volume, plus a specialist firm for the roles that stall. That blend is often the most practical talent acquisition strategy for a company between 50 and 300 employees.
Questions to ask any recruiting firm
- Which roles and markets do you actually specialize in?
- How do you verify what is on a resume, such as licenses, software skills or clearance level?
- How many candidates do you expect to submit, and how quickly?
- What does your fee cover, and what is your replacement guarantee?
- How will you represent our company to candidates who are not actively looking?
A strong answer to the second question matters most. Keyword matching fills inboxes. Verified submissions fill seats.
How Koger Talent works
Koger Talent is a Veteran-Owned Small Business that provides recruiting and HR advisory services for mid-sized companies. Most of our searches are contingency based, so there is no fee unless you hire one of our candidates. We recruit across government contracting and cleared roles, accounting and finance, engineering and healthcare, and we confirm the specific requirements of each role before a candidate reaches your inbox. Planning next year's hiring? Start with our guide to human capital planning for 2027.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between contingency and retained recruiting?
With contingency recruiting, you pay only when you hire a candidate the firm presented. With retained search, you pay part of the fee upfront for a firm's dedicated time and a defined process on one search.
Is contingency recruiting cheaper than retained search?
There is no upfront cost with contingency, and no fee if no hire is made. Retained search costs more up front but can be the better value for senior or confidential roles where a miss is expensive.
Should a mid-sized company hire an in-house recruiter or use an agency?
If you hire steadily for the same roles, an in-house recruiter usually pays off. If your hard roles are specialized or occasional, a specialist recruiting firm is often faster and cheaper than building that reach internally.
Can I use a recruiting firm and an in-house team at the same time?
Yes. Many companies keep in-house recruiters on core roles and bring in a specialist firm for niche or urgent searches.
Have a role that has been open too long? Tell us what the seat requires and we will tell you honestly whether contingency recruiting is the right fit.
